SIMENON SIMENON. ROWAN ATKINSON A-T-IL LAISSE' MR.BEAN TROP LOIN DERRIERE?
Quelques extraits de critiques sur la performance d’Atkinson en Maigret.
SIMENON SIMENON. ROWAN ATKINSON HA LASCIATO TROPPO LONTANO MR.BEAN?
Alcuni estratti, e relativi link, sulla performance di Atkinson nel Maigret della ITV
At long last, Maigret Sets a Trap played on television screens in the UK. Nearly six million viewers watched the 2-hour presentation. Alas, so did some critics. Below are some smatterings I collected from the latter, organized from positive to negative according to my interpretation. Note: the attributed citations are but headlines above and snippets within lengthy reviews. It behooves the reader to follow the included links and the full commentary. (Expect some links to be clickable and others to be copy-and-paste.)
“It is to be hoped that Georges Simenon would be proud of the terrific effort employed by all to bring Maigret Sets A Trap to the television screen.” Ian D. Hall http://www.liverpoolsoundandvision.co.uk/2016/03/29/maigret-sets-a-trap-television-review/
“His [Rowan Atkinson] understated performance… …was arguably closer to the feel of the books than previous actors….” Sarah Hughes http://www.pressreader.com/uk/i-from-the-independent/20160329/283338996387515/textview
“Overall, classier than vin ordinaire, but still an early vintage.” James Jackson http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/arts/tv-radio/reviews/article4723066.ece
“For Maigret’s first case… …it was alright….” Matt Baylis
“It was too ponderous, at times. But not bad for starters.” Gerard O’Donovan
“What saved this show was its richly imagined vision of Paris…. “ Christopher Stevens http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-3513103/Blackadder-French-Inspector-Morse-cunning-plan-CHRISTOPHER-STEVENS-Rowan-Atkinson-Jules-new-TV-crime-drama.html
“Atkinson failed to convince critics of his credentials as a heavyweight actor….” https://sg.celebrity.yahoo.com/post/141890687369/stringy-mr-bean-as-the-burly-pipe-smoking
“Soporific reinvention of Georges Simenon's veteran detective” Adam Sweeting http://www.theartsdesk.com/tv/maigret-itv
“Rowan Atkinson’s one-off TV film Maigret bored viewers to tears” Olivia Waring http://metro.co.uk/2016/03/29/rowan-atkinsons-one-off-tv-film-maigret-bored-viewers-to-tears-5782829/
“Rowan Atkinson's Maigret slammed by critics as Mr Bean actor's new role fails to impress” Danny Walker, Eleanor Bley Griffiths http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/rowan-atkinsons-maigret-slammed-critics-7648328
“Events unfolded so slowly… …I thought my watch had stopped.” Lucy Mangan
David P Simmons
So di esprimere un'opinione banale ma, IMHO, l'unico Maigret è il grande Gino Cervi.RispondiElimina